How should the Titans use their first overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft? Sorting five alternatives from worst to best

The Tennessee Titans, after a challenging 3-14 season, hold the first overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. This pivotal position offers them a unique opportunity to reshape their roster and address critical needs. Analyzing five potential strategies, we’ll rank them from least to most beneficial for the franchise’s future.

5. Selecting Ashton Jeanty, Running Back, Boise State

Ashton Jeanty has been a standout at Boise State, showcasing agility, vision, and playmaking abilities that have caught the attention of NFL scouts. His dynamic running style and versatility make him an intriguing prospect. However, using the first overall pick on a running back carries inherent risks.

The NFL has seen a devaluation of the running back position in recent years, with teams finding productive backs in later rounds or through free agency. Investing top draft capital in a running back may not yield the desired return on investment, especially considering the Titans’ broader roster needs. Additionally, the average career length of running backs is shorter compared to other positions, further complicating the value proposition.

While Jeanty’s talent is undeniable, the positional value and the Titans’ current roster composition suggest that this selection might not be the optimal use of the first overall pick.

4. Selecting Abdul Carter, Edge Rusher, Penn State

Abdul Carter has emerged as one of the premier defensive talents in this draft class. His explosive first step, combined with a relentless motor, has drawn comparisons to elite pass rushers in the league. Bolstering the pass rush is always a priority, and Carter’s potential impact cannot be understated.

However, the Titans’ defense, despite its struggles, has foundational pieces in place. Allocating the top pick to an edge rusher, while beneficial, might not address the most pressing issues facing the team. Furthermore, the depth of defensive talent in this draft suggests that high-quality pass rushers could be available in later rounds.

While Carter’s addition would undoubtedly strengthen the defense, the Titans might benefit more from addressing other critical areas with their premier selection.

3. Selecting Shedeur Sanders, Quarterback, Colorado

Shedeur Sanders has made significant strides during his collegiate career at Colorado. Known for his poise, accuracy, and football IQ, Sanders has demonstrated the qualities teams covet in a franchise quarterback. His ability to read defenses and deliver precise throws under pressure has been commendable.

However, the Titans’ recent investment in Will Levis complicates this potential selection. Drafting another quarterback so soon could signal a lack of confidence in Levis and might not provide the immediate upgrade the team desires. Additionally, Sanders’ arm strength has been a topic of discussion among scouts, raising questions about his ability to make all the necessary throws at the professional level.

While Sanders possesses many attributes of a successful NFL quarterback, the timing and fit with the Titans’ current roster dynamics make this selection less favorable.

2. Selecting Cam Ward, Quarterback, Miami

Cam Ward’s tenure at Miami has been marked by electrifying plays and a dynamic presence under center. His mobility, arm talent, and improvisational skills have drawn parallels to some of the league’s top quarterbacks. Ward’s ability to extend plays and create opportunities downfield adds a dimension that could invigorate the Titans’ offense.

However, similar to the considerations with Sanders, the presence of Will Levis presents a dilemma. Transitioning to a new quarterback requires significant adjustments and may not yield immediate results. Ward’s playstyle, while exciting, also comes with concerns about consistency and decision-making under pressure.

While Ward’s potential is enticing, the Titans must weigh the benefits of such a selection against the existing quarterback situation and the potential for addressing other areas of need.

1. Selecting Travis Hunter, Wide Receiver/Cornerback, Colorado

Travis Hunter is arguably the most versatile and dynamic player in this draft class. Excelling as both a wide receiver and cornerback at Colorado, Hunter’s athleticism, football instincts, and playmaking abilities make him a rare talent. His dual-threat capability offers the Titans flexibility in addressing multiple roster needs.

On offense, Hunter could provide a significant boost to the receiving corps, offering a reliable target with big-play potential. Defensively, his skills as a cornerback could enhance the secondary, providing depth and versatility. Selecting Hunter would not only address immediate needs but also add a player capable of impacting the game in various facets.

Given the Titans’ current roster composition and the potential immediate impact, Travis Hunter stands out as the most advantageous selection with the first overall pick.

While each of these prospects brings unique talents and potential to the table, the Titans must carefully evaluate their immediate needs and long-term goals. Prioritizing a player like Travis Hunter, who offers versatility and addresses multiple areas of need, appears to be the most strategic approach for maximizing the value of their first overall selection.